7 Steps to Getting a Non Conviction for Criminal Charges
Last Updated: November 4, 2026
Quick Summary
A non conviction outcome is when the court finds the offence proven but exercises its discretion under section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) to dismiss the charge or discharge you without recording a conviction. A finding of guilt and a recorded conviction are two separate things, so a guilty plea does not end your chance to argue for no conviction.
Section 10 offers dismissal with no conditions, conditional discharge, or discharge with a fine, all without a conviction.
Serious offences, prior criminal history, and lack of remorse reduce the likelihood of a non conviction.
Early guilty pleas, genuine remorse, rehabilitation, and character references improve your chances.
A National Police Check can still disclose charges dismissed without conviction.
Visa, licensing, and professional registration applications may require disclosure of charges even without a conviction.
Table of Contents
Step 1: Understand What a Non Conviction Outcome Actually Means
A non conviction outcome is a court finding that you are guilty of an offence but that no conviction is recorded against you. For the full range of sentencing and penalty options available in NSW, see our guide. (Source: NSW legislation on the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999)
The key point most people miss: a finding of guilt and a recorded conviction are two separate things. The court can find the offence proven and still choose not to record a conviction. That distinction sits at the heart of getting a non conviction for criminal charges.
Finding of Guilt Without a Recorded Conviction
A finding of guilt means the court is satisfied the offence happened. A recorded conviction is the formal entry on your criminal record. The law lets a court find guilt but decline to record a conviction, usually after weighing your character, the offence, and the likely impact on your life.
This is not a loophole. It is a discretionary outcome, and the court takes it seriously. A guilty plea does not end the discussion; it is often the start of the argument for no conviction.
Step 2: Check How a Section 10 Dismissal NSW Works
A Section 10 dismissal NSW is the main pathway to a no conviction recorded NSW outcome. Section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) allows the court to dismiss a charge without recording a conviction.
There are a few versions of this order:
Section 10(1)(a): dismissal with no conditions
Section 10(1)(b): conditional discharge, where you must be of good behaviour
Section 10(1)(c): discharge with a fine, but still no conviction
The court can also order you to enter a good behaviour bond. The NSW legislation on the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 sets out the exact wording and conditions. For a fuller picture of the sentencing pathways that sit around this order, see sentencing options in NSW.
Step 3: Know When No Conviction Recorded NSW Is Realistic
A no conviction recorded NSW outcome is never automatic. The court exercises discretion under section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW), and the likelihood of a dismissal depends on a combination of offence seriousness, your personal circumstances, and the quality of the evidence you present. Non-conviction orders are generally considered in the Local Court for summary offences, but they are not limited to minor matters.
Offence Seriousness and Prior Criminal History
The more serious the criminal offence, the harder a non conviction becomes. Courts look closely at prior convictions and any pattern of offending. A first offence carries far more weight than a fifth. However, seriousness is not just about the label on the charge, the actual circumstances matter.
Watch out: assuming a minor charge guarantees a dismissal. The court still examines the circumstances of the offence, not just the label on the charge. A common pattern is that even first-time offenders can be denied a section 10 if the offence involved a breach of trust, violence, or a vulnerable victim.
Eligibility Limits and Realistic Outcome Expectations
There is no strict eligibility checklist for a non conviction, but certain factors reduce the likelihood. These include:
Serious offences: Indictable offences, sexual assault, or offences involving violence often attract recorded convictions.
Prior criminal history: A pattern of offending, even minor, can undermine the argument for leniency.
Lack of remorse or insight: The court looks for genuine remorse and steps towards rehabilitation.
Aggravating circumstances: Offences committed in a position of trust, with planning, or against vulnerable victims are less likely to result in a dismissal.
On the other hand, strong mitigating factors can improve the chances. These include early guilty pleas, youth, mental health conditions, evidence of rehabilitation, and severe hardship to family or employment. A well-prepared sentencing submission that ties these factors to the legal test is essential.
The court is generally more willing to grant a section 10 where the offence is at the lower end of seriousness and the defendant can demonstrate concrete steps towards reform. However, outcomes are never guaranteed, and each case turns on its own facts. If you are unsure about your prospects, get advice tailored to your circumstances.
Step 4: Identify the Factors for No Conviction Recorded in Your Case
The factors for no conviction recorded are the evidence and arguments that persuade the court to exercise its discretion. These are the levers that decide whether you walk out with a clean record.
Mitigating and Aggravating Factors the Court Weighs
Mitigating factors help your case. Aggravating factors hurt it.
Mitigating: early guilty plea, genuine remorse, rehabilitation, good character, youth, mental health, hardship to family or employment
Aggravating: prior convictions, planning, vulnerability of a victim, offence in a position of trust
Character references and a well-prepared sentencing submission carry real weight here. If your matter involves a drug charge, our drug possession lawyers can explain how these factors are argued in practice.
Step 5: Prepare the Evidence and Sentencing Submission
Strong evidence turns a hopeful argument into a persuasive one. A sentencing submission is the document and oral argument that sets out why the court should exercise its discretion.

Prepare:
Character references from people who know you well
Evidence of rehabilitation, such as courses or treatment
Proof of employment, study, or family responsibility
A written submission that ties the facts to the legal test
A common mistake is a vague reference letter that says nothing specific. Courts see through generic praise. For tips on how to handle the courtroom itself, read our guide to negotiating with magistrates.
Step 6: Understand Non Conviction and Police Checks
A non conviction and police checks are linked in ways most people do not expect. Even without a recorded conviction, some police checks can still show that a charge was dealt with by the court. The key is to understand which check reveals what, and what you are legally obliged to disclose.
Spent Conviction Rules and Disclosure
A section 10 dismissal is not a conviction, so it is treated differently under the spent conviction rules. Generally, a dismissal without a conviction does not form part of your criminal record for most purposes, but it may still appear on some police checks.
There are two main types of police checks:
National Police Check (NPC): This check discloses all disclosable court outcomes, including charges that were dismissed without conviction. However, spent convictions are not included unless the check is for an exempt purpose (such as working with children or in certain government roles).
Working with Children Check (WWCC): This check is more thorough and may reveal dismissed charges, as it assesses risk to children.
Watch out: assuming a non conviction is invisible on all checks. For certain roles, such as those involving children, vulnerable people, or financial services, you may be required to disclose even spent convictions or dismissed charges. Always read the disclosure requirements carefully.
Consequences for Visas, Licensing, and Professional Registration
A non conviction can still have consequences beyond standard police checks. For example:
Visas: Many visa applications require disclosure of all criminal charges, even those that did not result in a conviction. Failure to disclose can lead to visa cancellation or refusal.
Licensing: Professional or occupational licensing bodies (such as for law, medicine, or real estate) may have their own disclosure requirements and may consider dismissed charges when assessing fitness to practise.
Employment: Some employers, particularly in sensitive sectors, may ask about charges that did not result in a conviction. You should seek advice on what you are legally required to disclose.
The Australian Government's guidance on police checks explains how different checks work. It is important to get advice on your specific circumstances, as the rules vary depending on the type of check and who is asking.
Step 7: Avoid the Mistakes That Sink a Non Conviction Application
The most common mistakes are avoidable. Each one can cost you the outcome you want.
Mistake | Why it hurts | What to do instead |
Pleading guilty without advice | Gives up the chance to argue no conviction | Get legal advice before entering a plea |
Generic character references | Carries little weight with the court | Use specific, detailed references |
No rehabilitation evidence | Suggests no insight into the offence | Show concrete steps you have taken |
Missing the sentencing submission | Leaves the argument unmade | Prepare a written submission |
Hiding prior history | Damages credibility | Disclose and address it openly |
The biggest error is treating a guilty plea as the end of the matter. It is often the beginning of the argument.
Book a Free Consultation Before Your Court Date
Court dates move fast, and the argument for a non conviction is strongest when it is prepared early. At Invictus Legal, we offer a 30-minute initial consultation to review your matter and your options, with fixed fee options available so you know where you stand. Our team is available 24/7 for urgent charges, and we handle matters across NSW, not just the city. We focus on protecting your rights and pushing for the best outcome the law allows.
Get started with Invictus Legal and give yourself the best chance at a clean record. Book a 30-minute initial consultation with our team today.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a non conviction outcome mean?
A non conviction outcome means the court finds the offence proved or accepts a guilty plea but decides not to record a conviction. In NSW this is commonly done under Section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999, which allows the court to dismiss the charge, discharge the person conditionally, or discharge them on a good behaviour bond. The practical effect is that no conviction is recorded against you, which matters for police checks, employment and travel.
Can you receive a non conviction outcome for any criminal charge?
No. A non conviction is discretionary and courts generally reserve it for less serious offences, first offences, or matters where strong mitigating factors exist. Serious indictable offences, matters involving violence, or cases with prior convictions rarely attract a Section 10 dismissal NSW. The magistrate or judge weighs offence seriousness, your criminal history, your prospects of rehabilitation and the circumstances of the offence before deciding.
Does a non conviction appear on a criminal record or police check?
A non conviction generally does not appear on a standard police check as a recorded conviction, though the underlying charge may still be disclosed in some circumstances, such as certain employment screening or working with children checks. The interaction between non conviction and police checks depends on the type of check and the spent conviction legislation that applies. It is worth getting advice on what will and will not be disclosed before you apply for a role or a visa.
Can a lawyer help prepare a submission for a non conviction outcome?
Yes. A lawyer can gather character references, treatment records, rehabilitation evidence and a written sentencing submission that addresses the factors for no conviction recorded. They can also advise on the realistic prospects, negotiate with the prosecution, and present the case to the magistrate in a way that gives the non conviction application its best chance. Early advice usually produces better preparation than a last-minute request on the court date.
The outcome of a criminal charge often turns on preparation in the weeks before court. A non conviction is within reach for many first-time and minor matters, but it is never automatic. Speak to a lawyer early, gather the right evidence, and make the argument properly.




Comments