top of page
Search

How To Contest A Mobile Phone Fine In NSW?

Jul 3, 2024
5 min read

Updated: Oct 12

Receiving a mobile phone fine can be frustrating and may often feel unjust. If you've been penalised in New South Wales and believe it was a mistake or unfair, you have the right to challenge it. 


To contest a mobile phone fine in NSW, initiate a review with Revenue NSW or choose to challenge the penalty in Court. Should the initial review fail, you have the legal option to continue your fight in the Local Court.


Knowing how to contest a mobile phone fine in NSW not only helps you possibly overturn this fine but also ensures you are treated fairly under the law. Let’s get into the details of this process. 

How To Contest A Mobile Phone Fine In NSW - A Quick Answer

Contesting a mobile phone fine in NSW starts with checking your penalty notice to understand the alleged offence and ensure all details are correct. Gathering evidence, such as phone records, dash cam footage or witness accounts, is important. You can ask Revenue NSW to review the fine, and whether or not you seek a review, you can elect to have the matter heard in the Local Court, provided you do so by the due date on the penalty reminder notice (Fines Act 1996 (NSW) ss 24A, 36).

Need Legal Assistance in Australia? Invictus Legal Is Here to Help

If you're navigating the complexities of legal issues in Australia, don't face them alone. At Invictus Legal, we provide expert guidance and assertive representation to ensure your rights are protected. Whether you're contesting a mobile phone fine or dealing with more complex legal matters, our team is equipped with the knowledge and experience to support you. Trust us to deliver clarity and results when you need them most. 


For personalised legal advice, call us on 02 8553 0500 or visit our Contact Us page. For urgent matters, such as an arrest, a bail application or urgent injunctive relief, call our 24/7 urgent line on 0410 600 230.

Steps to Contest a Mobile Phone Fine in NSW

Contesting a mobile phone fine in NSW requires understanding the legal framework and procedures in place. This section navigates through the initial steps of challenging your fine, starting from the moment you receive your notice.

Understanding Your Fine Notice

When you receive a fine notice, the first step is to thoroughly review the document. Check the date, the offence stated and the penalty amount. It’s crucial to understand whether the fine aligns with the actual circumstances under which the offence is claimed to have occurred. This initial review will determine the direction of your contestation efforts.

Gathering Evidence

Collecting robust evidence is fundamental in contesting any fine. For a mobile phone violation, this could include GPS data, phone logs or even eyewitness accounts that support your claim that you were not in violation of the law. High-quality, relevant evidence can significantly strengthen your case, especially if it contradicts the details noted by the issuing officer.

Submitting a Formal Review Request

To start the formal process, request a review from Revenue NSW (online, or by calling 1300 138 118). Include your evidence and a clear, concise statement of why the fine should be withdrawn. A review can generally be requested at any time, but if you have already paid the fine and no penalty reminder notice was issued, you must apply within 60 days (Fines Act 1996 (NSW) s 24A). If the review is unsuccessful, you can still elect to have the matter heard in court by the due date on the penalty reminder notice (s 36).

Preparing for Your Court Appearance

If the review does not resolve in your favour, the next step is to elect to have the matter heard in the Local Court and prepare for your court appearance. Be aware that if the court finds the offence proved, it can impose a fine higher than the penalty notice amount, plus court costs, and the demerit points will still apply. If you accept that the offence occurred but have strong reasons, the court may decide not to record a conviction (Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) s 10), in which case no demerit points are recorded. Consulting a lawyer before you go to court can help you decide the best approach.

Appeal Process

If the Local Court decides against you, you can appeal to the District Court. Strict time limits apply (generally 28 days from the Local Court decision), so seek advice promptly.

Possible Mobile Phone Offences

Awareness of what constitutes a mobile phone offence in NSW is crucial not only for driving safely but also for understanding your rights in contesting a fine.

  • Using a Hand-held Mobile Phone

  • Texting While Driving

  • Recording Video or Taking Photos

  • Using Mobile Phone When Not Permitted

Each of these actions is illegal when driving unless an exception applies, and can result in a fine and 5 demerit points, with double demerits during holiday periods. Learner, P1 and P2 drivers must not use a mobile phone at all while driving, even hands-free or in a holder (Road Rules 2014 (NSW) r 300-1).

Defences for Mobile Phone Offences

Knowing possible defences is essential for effectively contesting your fine. Here are some scenarios where defences can be applicable:

Emergency Situations

The mobile phone rules do not contain a general emergency exception. In limited cases the common law defence of necessity may be available, and genuine emergency circumstances can be relevant to a review or to a court's decision whether to record a conviction. Evidence such as phone records or a witness statement can support your account.

Mistaken Identity

If a camera-detected fine was issued to you as the registered owner but someone else was driving, you can nominate the actual driver through Revenue NSW by the due date on the notice. Knowingly making a false nomination is a serious offence.

Faulty Fine Issuance

Occasionally, fines are issued incorrectly due to either human error or misinterpretation of the situation. Detailed evidence contrasting the officer’s report can be a strong defence.

Permissible Use Under Law

Some uses of a mobile phone are permitted for fully licensed drivers: making or receiving calls or playing audio hands-free without touching the phone, or using the phone for calls, audio or navigation while it is secured in a commercially manufactured holder fixed to the vehicle. Any driver may use a phone when parked out of the line of traffic. These driving exceptions do not apply to learner, P1 or P2 drivers (Road Rules 2014 (NSW) rr 300, 300-1). Demonstrating that your use fell within an exception can be a strong defence.

Final Thoughts

Challenging a mobile phone fine in NSW is more than just about dodging a fee; it's about standing up for your rights and ensuring fair treatment. With the right approach and comprehensive preparation, you can navigate this challenge with confidence and possibly reverse the decision of your fine. 

Whether you're gathering evidence, submitting a formal review or taking your case to court, each step is an opportunity to assert your rights and understand the legal framework better. Remember, you're not alone in this process, and understanding your legal rights is the first step towards a successful outcome.

 
 
 

1 Comment


James Smith
James Smith
May 16, 2025

For anyone searching for a reliable mobile shop, Cellfixx is a great choice. They offer expert phone repairs and top-quality service at competitive prices!

Like
bottom of page